User blog:Scrooge200/Season 3 Review

Note: This review is in progress.

Since Season 2 was better than Season 1, will Season 3 be better? I hope so!

I will rate each episode on a scale from Vomitrocious, Bad, Okay, Good, Great. At the end of my review, I'll count up how many of each rating there are in the season, and give it a rating as a whole, alongside ranking every episode in the season from best to worst.

I have currently reviewed 21/30 episodes in Season 3.

Buster's Back

I get that Arthur is excited about Buster returning (and to be honest, I kind of am too), but the way he runs out of the house screaming "BUSTER'S COMING HOME!" (he even defies physics to show Muffy a piece of paper underwater) is a little too hard to take seriously. Arthur goes through many wild mood swings; from excitement, to worry, to trying to conform to the "new Buster" (before he even knows if anything has changed), to absolute rage. And I don't like that he's doing all this before he has even talked to Buster again. When Buster's plane lands, Arthur camps by the phone and waits for Buster to call him. Even though Buster would have to get to his home phone since cell phones weren't commonplace at this time. And when Buster doesn't call (I don't know, maybe because he isn't home?), he starts getting really mad and insists that he doesn't need Buster anymore.

What about "Arthur's Faraway Friend," "Arthur the Loser," and "Arthur the Unfunny," in which we see Arthur and Buster writing letters back and forth to each other? Wouldn't Arthur be able to tell that Buster hasn't changed? This episode cheapens the ending of "Arthur's Faraway Friend."

Although I didn't like "Buster's New Friend," at least there was good reason for Arthur to believe that Buster doesn't want to be friends with him anymore. Here, he's throwing away his pictures of Buster before he has even seen him back in Elwood City. The resolution where Buster just wants to play checkers is kind of lame. Not a good return for the character. Bad episode. And this is my longest review since "Arthur's Eyes."

The Ballad of Buster Baxter

This episode starts exactly where "Buster's Back" ends. But both episodes have different plots; while "Buster's Back" is about Arthur worrying that Buster has changed, Buster finds it's the opposite and that while he hasn't changed, everyone and everything else has. And this episode has a lot of call-backs to the previous season, and all the events that happened while Buster was gone. One of the most important ones, though, makes no sense. Why would Arthur and Brain have continued Buster's Robin Hood story? "Arthur's Faraway Friend" ends with them continuing the story, and Arthur even being excited about it! Also, Muffy thinking Buster is a snob comes out of nowhere and ends in nothing. I don't get this plot.

Oh, and of course, there's Art Garfunkel. He's definitely the best part of the episode, as his songs are really funny. But can he redeem this nonsensical episode? Nope, it's okay. Buster's return is pretty underwhelming, but I'm glad to have a main character back.

D.W. All Fired Up

I like this episode. It teaches some good fire safety tips. Arthur is surprisingly nice here, as he reassures D.W. that the school isn't set on fire, tells her not to wear the wet towel because she'll catch a cold, and asks if she's okay after the fire drill. It reminds me of "Operation: D.W.!" I like that even though the Tibbles start the episode's conflict by telling D.W. that she'll be lit on fire, she still helps them when they have trouble during the fire drill. Overall, this is a good episode.

I'd Rather Read It Myself

I really enjoyed D.W.'s story. It did call-backs way better than "The Ballad of Buster Baxter." This episode is really funny, from Bustrantor's song, to Mr. Haney falling in a tiger trap, to all the references, to the book actually being about Leonardo da Vinci. The ending of this episode is good, as the Tibbles still believe that D.W. can read and that the book is magic, so everyone is happy. Great episode. If Season 3 is going to continue being like this and "D.W. All Fired Up," then I can't wait to see what's next!

Arthur Goes Crosswire

I think Arthur only started acting OOC and stuck-up at the "don't you have satellite TV?" bit. Arthur acting so stuck-up from rescuing Wilbur Rabbit doesn't make too much sense. He doesn't seem like the kind of person to behave like that. And if he's really supposed to be acting like Muffy, they should've done a better job, because it seems more like he thinks he's famous when he really isn't. And this is annoying. The episode's climax is okay, I guess, but mostly because they use an extended version of a song commonly heard in the show. This episode's gone haywire; bad.

Sue Ellen and the Brainasaurous

There's a baffling subplot in this episode about Buster trying to hide from Francine. It's not funny and doesn't make much sense. I completely forgot about it before rewatching the episode. And that's the best way to describe this episode; I completely forgot about it. It's just not very interesting. There's not much of a conflict, which is probably why that stupid subplot was added. Brain works on a model and doesn't want Sue Ellen to help. That's pretty much it. I'll give this episode an okay, but keep it in mind as a cure for insomnia.

Background Blues

Three episodes in a row about class assignments? Thankfully, this episode is more interesting. This episode has a lot of new characters, but not many of them actually do anything. Francine and Muffy's contest feels out-of-place. It's like a repeat of "Arthur and the True Francine." I don't like Francine cutting her grandfather's picture just for the contest. This is a very average and unmemorable episode; okay.

And Now Let's Talk to Some Kids

The first half of this episode is hilarious. I love all the meta jokes, and my favorite is "Every day when you're walking down the street, you stop and think!" But I don't like the second half as much. The part where everyone on the show is kind of dull, and I don't like that they don't leave Brain alone. I think it makes the episode go from a great to a good.

The Chips are Down

Arthur and Buster convince D.W. she has been poisoned and will die soon just because she ate one of their potato chips. Thankfully, this leads to some very wholesome moments involving Binky and D.W., and I really like it. The part of Binky convincing Mr. Haney to climb a mountain is really stupid, but I do like the part where Binky does ballet. And the ending with the aliens who do ballet... that was just weird. I think there are enough negatives to make this episode okay instead of good.

Revenge of the Chip

Revenge of the chip? More like Revenge of Jerk Arthur. I hate all of Arthur's insults here. And no, I don't care that he brought D.W. to a show about embarrassing things. While "The Chips are Down" wasn't the best, this episode removed the wholesome moments that made that one better. I don't like that Jane has already told people the story without even asking D.W. how she feels about it. And is that story really that funny? Surely D.W. has done more amusing stuff. Jane treats D.W. thinking she's going to die as a joke! Ugh. Bad episode.

Binky Rules

Why would they blame Binky for some random graffiti? Is there seriously only one person in Elwood City named Binky? The boys vs. girls part is annoying and not needed. This episode is kind of boring. The only thing I'm wondering is why did they choose a band from Finland out of everything? It's not even called Binky! And they don't even play most of the song! A strange episode. Okay.

Meet Binky

I don't like that Arthur considers not taking his friends to the concert. It's pretty selfish. This episode has some funny moments, but not a lot. Like "Binky TAXES!" And the part about the holograms... what? It moves too fast for me to comprehend. I don't know how kids are supposed to understand this. Another Binky weird episode, which gets a Binky okay rating from me.

Arthur Rides the Bandwagon

Well, I like the Woogles commercial. But that's the only good thing about this episode. I don't get what this plot is supposed to be. Arthur should just give in to the fad, since he clearly does like Woogles, judging by his reaction when holding Buster's. Instead of just accepting Francine's one, he runs around in denial, getting a knockoff and a pet rock until finally he starts a new fad in an insanely stupid ending. I also find it kind of unrealistic that everyone in town has Woogles and just got them before they were very popular in the first place. Yeah, fads do get popular, but not to this degree. What a huge mess. If "I'd Rather Read It Myself" was a Woogle, this episode would be a Poogle. Bad.

Dad's Dessert Dilemma

Hey, this is the first episode featuring Arthur's dad. Well, there's "Arthur's Family Vacation," but we don't talk about that one. I don't like that Arthur uses his dad's desserts just to get popular and even starts promising cakes before he talks to his dad about it. He's being really inconsiderate here. He does hear the consequences of his actions and how his dad may lose Mr. Crosswire's business, but if he hadn't heard that, I think he would have carried out his request for over ten desserts. I do like the scene of Arthur and D.W. helping him cook. And Mr. Ratburn is really funny here. Oh, are you having good episode? No, this is an okay one.

Popular Girls

The community center setting is a nice change of pace. This episode has some funny moments and great quotes, such as "If we end up eating our friends, do we fail the test?" and "I might as well stick my tongue in a drawer and never blow again!" I like how this episode points out how stupid personality tests are and that you shouldn't take them seriously. This episode is about Fern and Sue Ellen acting out-of-character, and it leads to an interesting plot. I like how messed up everything gets without their help. Overall, a breath of fresh air from some of the particularly mean episodes we've gotten before. Good.

Buster's Growing Grudge

What an out-of-character episode for Buster. Binky tells a joke at the end of his report and Buster starts making up all these ridiculous claims that Binky's report got a good grade because of the joke, that people think Binky is funny instead of him, that not telling the joke got him a D... When Binky falls in the mud, Buster laughs and says that he "feels better already"! I get that Buster was rude on occasion in Season 1, but this is Season 3. They have established Buster's personality at this point, and this is completely not something he would do. He rants about Binky during the talent joke and he says that he won't be happy until Binky is "totally miserable all the time"... The resolution where Binky pays Buster 75 cents even though he didn't really do anything wrong doesn't help this episode. Vomitrocious.

Arthur's Treasure Hunt

The digestive biscuits part is funny. But other than that, this episode is really boring and goes on forever. It feels like they only had enough plot to fill four minutes, and then padded it out to ridiculous lengths. A very okay episode.

The Return of the King

I like how this episode gives some explanation as to why Mr. Ratburn gives such hard schoolwork. I like the contests between these weird lookalikes from Glenbrook and the Lakewood students, but the fact that Lakewood mostly loses because of Glenbrook cheating or the rules not being explained beforehand kind of cheapens it. I didn't think the whole part with Mr. Ratburn being replaced with Mr. Pryce-Jones (or so they think) was needed. An upper okay episode.

Attack of the Turbo Tibbles

I don't get why D.W. is punished here. I completely understand her not liking the Tibbles' obsession with the show, especially because it actually is impacting them during school. The Tibbles are kind of annoying and we get a lot of scenes of them watching the show and acting it out. Overall, an episode that would be unmemorable if not for the fact that D.W. breaks her face. An okay episode.

D.W. Tricks the Tooth Fairy

More like D.W.'s Tooth. This episode is just a rehash of "Arthur's Tooth." It does try to do something different towards the end, but why wouldn't Arthur tell her? He tries to get the shark tooth back only because he wants money, not because he cares about D.W. I don't get it. Or why wouldn't he tell her another way to get money? This show is the master of "character does X job for money" plots. The scene of Arthur and his friends dancing with their teeth moving individually is creepy and goes on for too long. This episode is not funny, not original, does not have a coherent plot. Light bad it is.

Double Tibble Trouble

I like D.W. and Emily in this episode and how they help Tommy. Arthur is even nice here, as he tells D.W. that sometimes being a good friend can be hard. I like this episode, even though the comedy isn't the best, for the story alone. It's good, even though the ending could have been better.

Season Notes

• There are many episodes in this season that are sequels to earlier ones. "Revenge of the Chip" to "The Chips are Down," "Sue Ellen and the Brainasaurous" to "Arthur Goes Crosswire," "D.W. Tricks the Tooth Fairy" to "Arthur's Tooth," and "Meet Binky" to "Binky Rules."

Rating Counts

• Great: 1
• Good: 4
• Okay: 10
• Bad: 5
• Vomitrocious: 1

Season Ranking

1. I'd Rather Read It Myself
2. And Now Let's Talk to Some Kids
3. Popular Girls
4. Double Tibble Trouble
5. D.W. All Fired Up
6. The Return of the King
7. The Chips are Down
8. Attack of the Turbo Tibbles
9. Background Blues
10. Dad's Dessert Dilemma
11. Binky Rules
12. Arthur's Treasure Hunt
13. Meet Binky
14. The Ballad of Buster Baxter
15. Sue Ellen and the Brainasaurous
16. D.W. Tricks the Tooth Fairy
17. Buster's Back
18. Arthur Goes Crosswire
19. Revenge of the Chip
20. Arthur Rides the Bandwagon
21. Buster's Growing Grudge