All Thumbs

Summary
When Arthur catches Buster sucking his thumb, Buster worries that Arthur will tell the entire school. Can Arthur stay mum? Or is this secret just too juicy not to share?

Plot
Arthur comes to Buster's for a movie, but when he gets there, he sees Buster sucking his thumb.

-All Thumbs-

Arthur leaves and comes to his house, where he tells his parents about Buster sucking his thumb. Buster has a fantasy where his parents tell all the parents. He sends Arthur an email saying it wasn't a big deal. Arthur has a fantasy where people think he's weird for hanging out with Buster, who sucks his thumb.

When Buster comes to see him, he runs. Arthur and Francine sit with Muffy, Sue Ellen, Brain, and Binky, who ask why Buster didn't sit with them. Buster tries to listen, but falls out of his seat. Arthur tries to talk with Buster, who runs away. Muffy and Francine follow, and Francine hears.

Francine comes to Buster, and gives him something, which makes your thumbs taste bad. She proceeds to tell him that she sucks her thumb sometimes, too. Buster comes and tells Arthur that he has stopped, and the two become best friends again.

Characters

 * Arthur Read
 * Buster Baxter
 * Francine Frensky
 * Muffy Crosswire
 * Binky Barnes
 * Alan "The Brain" Powers
 * Sue Ellen Armstrong
 * George Lundgren
 * Fern Walters
 * Ladonna Compson (background)
 * Rafi (background)

Episode connections

 * The plot is similar to the one in "I Wanna Hold Your Hand", as Binky tries to get George not to tell anyone about him holding his mom's hand.

Production notes

 * On the title card, Dietrich Smith's name is misspelled as 'Dietrick Smith'.