Ungifted

Summary
Arthur gives away a present that he had received from Buster.

Plot
Buster digs out an old model called The Grain Reaper that he found in the closet and builds it. However, he has trouble figuring out where the last piece of the model goes. Arthur comes by to tell Buster that movie posters are being given out at the Mill Creek Cinema, but when Arthur gets a chance to visit the movie theater, Binky has already bought the last poster. Binky spots the model thresher and Arthur trades it for the poster. Arthur shows Buster the poster and explains how he got it, but Buster is unhappy. Arthur tries to make a sorry card for Buster, but he rejects it. That night, Arthur has a bad dream where the thresher's "mother" is invading Buster's house. Arthur desperately asks to get the model back, but the Tibble Twins destroy it on a little touchdown celebration by playing a little "offensive football" on a pass play. Later, Arthur visits Buster while his family is still having dinner. Arthur gives Buster the repaired model and Buster is happy again. The episode finishes with Buster choosing another model at a store.

Characters

 * Arthur Read
 * Buster Baxter
 * Binky Barnes
 * Bitzi Baxter
 * Stu (debut)
 * D.W. Read
 * Mrs. Tibble
 * Timmy and Tommy Tibble
 * Muffy Crosswire (opening)
 * The Brain
 * Mr. Ratburn
 * Thora Read (imagination)
 * George Lundgren (imagination)
 * Neal Lundgren (imagination)
 * Mrs. Fink (cameo)
 * Sue Ellen Armstrong (cameo)
 * Patrick (4th grader) (cameo)
 * Alfonz (cameo)
 * Prunella Deegan (cameo)
 * Mary (cameo)
 * Pal (cameo in imagination)
 * Francine Frensky (cameo in imagination)
 * Oliver Frensky (cameo in imagination)

Trivia

 * Arthur's laugh in the title card is in a lower pitch.
 * Sue Ellen and Patrick can be seen outside the movie theater. Strangely, they do not move at all.
 * The Bionic Bunny Walkie-Talkies make another appearance.
 * Timeline: A poster for the Harvest Day Celebration that is mentioned in "Arthur's Number Nightmare" can be seen in the library. The Harvest Day Celebration would be mentioned again in "Prunella and the Disappointing Ending."

Errors

 * The video description refers to George as "Moose".
 * When Buster is first shown holding the model combine kit at the end of the episode, one of the box's sides misspells "COMBINE" as "COMBIVE".

Cultural references

 * The Grain Reaper is a reference to the.
 * Convert-o-nauts refer to.
 * The introduction combines elements from “Hans in Luck” and “Jack and the Beanstalk”.
 * Arthur and Buster's shoe-shaped house in the introduction may refer to the old woman who lived in a shoe.
 * "Dark Bunny vs. the Cisco Squid" refers to “”.

Home Video

 * DVD: The Ultimate Friendship Collection