What's in a Name?

 What's in a Name? is the second half of the 6th episode of Season 15. It first aired on April 16, 2012 with "Prunella the Pack Rat."

Summary
Muffy threatens to reveal Binky's real name, Shelley, after she thinks his winning the class award for most improved student is undeserved.

Plot
Opening Arthur is busy when D.W. brings in a new stuffed animal and she makes him help her name her stuffed animal. Arthur goes over how its an elaborate process, and as such, D.W. must be blind-folded and spun around, then the first letter of the first thing she sees will be the first letter of the objects name. Then she drinks milk with cinnamon and chants random words before kicking her legs and sipping the drink through her curly straw. She then takes a nap with the doll under the pillow where she proceeds to dream of the doll or stuffed animal. Arthur mentions then she eventually gets a name. The penguin shall be named Xeno! Arthur then asks why names are so important to some people... Episode Mr. Ratburn goes on to give a special award to a student who truly deserves it, stating that he only gives out one normally but this was a very special award, so he's given a second one to Binky! Binky is very surprised and is asked to say a few words. As he stands up he hears Muffy discussing something over the cellphone during his speech until scolding her and asking her to be quiet.

Muffy is then in trouble as Mr. Ratburn claims she has done this 4 times previously and she's been very rude to Binky. So he takes her cellphone away, as well as Muffy is banned for an entire week from Recess. Everyone is in shock as Muffy grows angry, she goes to leave but is reminded that she has to stay back. While inside Muffy staples together papers when Mr. Haney comes inside and mentions how beautiful and nice today is. Unaware that Muffy is actually in trouble. He asks her to give the class list to Mr. Ratburn and looks over it to see her name, then notices someone named "Shelly Barnes". She asks who that is and is quick to recognize the name.

At the end of the day she sits in her limo as Binky walks by. She then confronts him over it, but Binky denies this accusation and she shows him the class list to prove how right she is. It's then Muffy threatens to reveal his name on Monday.

At home, Binky's mother even tells him that his name is really Shelly. Binky is noticeably upset and mentions how annoyed he is by being named Shelly. She tries to tell him that she'll keep it a secret and right away Binky sends a message to Muffy and asks her what she wants in order to keep his secret a secret. Unfortunately, he cannot provide either thing and he lays in bed that night imagining what everybody will do when they hear of his real name. He expects that everybody will mock him, including Mr. Ratburn.

It's then Binky's mother comes into the room with some food. She then shows him a very old photo of his great grandfather: Shelly Barnes.

Binky asks her about his position in the circus and she mentions he eventually owned the circus. Originally he was in a, somewhat-bad circus and nobody really had fun. While a nine year old, Shelly would help the trapeze artist prepare, a heartbroken clown, the lion tamer as his apprentice. Eventually nobody would come anymore and one day while on a walk, Shelly found his talent! He became known as the worlds strongest boy and with all of the money they were making, they managed to fix the problems. Such as providing a real, friendly lion, a trapeze artist partner, and they gave the old lion (a cat) to the sad clown. So Shelly saved the circus.

Binky begins to feel a bit happier now, knowing how amazing his ancestor was and soon the following Monday he resumes his speech. But not before Muffy interrupts and asks to introduce Binky, really planning on giving away his secret. However, she then quits, stating that she was never really going to spoil his secret. At the front of the class Binky then reveals it himself! Arthur questions this and Binky explains how he just found out his real name was Shelly. But he still wishes to be known as Binky, but maybe someday he'll become Shelly.

Trivia

 * On Xfinity, this episode is the second half of the episode, not the first.