Arthur the Loser

Arthur the Loser is the second half of episode seventeen of Season 2. It first aired on March 23, 1998, along with "Francine Redecorates".

Summary
Arthur keeps losing at the new No Guessing board game and other things as well, so he starts cheating to win. His friends are annoyed by his "sore winner" attitude and use Binky to make Arthur lose, because Binky has no qualms about cheating. Arthur then gives up because he imagines Buster telling him what the right thing to do would be. Subsequently, he writes about the situation and a thanks in a letter to Buster, which leaves Buster confused.

Plot Outline
The story begins with Arthur's basketball team facing Binky's team at school. Arthur confidently assures his team that if Francine passes him the ball, he'll score the winning point. Once Francine passes it to Arthur, he dodges Binky and scores the winning basket, earning him the praise of his team. However, the whole event turns out to be a daydream. Arthur comes to in the middle of the game and takes the shot, but misses and his team loses. Arthur remarks how hard it is to win sometimes.

One day at home, Arthur watches TV and sees an ad for No Guessing!, a trivia board game where you have to answers as many questions correctly in order to win. Arthur really wants the game and eventually buys it with his own money. He goes up to play it in the treehouse against himself and wins. Suddenly, Brain shows up so they play the game together. Unfortunately, Arthur gets the questions wrong so Brain wins, leaving Arthur disappointed. Later, he plays against Francine, and loses once again. Finally, after losing to Sue Ellen, Arthur becomes a sore loser and stashes the game under his bed, too frustrated to try again.

In the days that follow, Arthur is on a losing streak, losing at every game against his friends, including video games, checkers, bowling, among others. His dad assures him he will get lucky and start winning again, but Arthur isn't so sure. D.W. offers to play a game of cards with him to help his luck change (Even though she just wants to beat him before that happens). After a while, Arthur has only one card left and D.W. is about to beat him for the first time ever. When she asks if Arthur has a seven, he does, but lies and says he doesn't, afraid that she'll tell everyone. He then tricks her into looking in another direction and looks at her cards, and easily beats her by cheating. D.W. is shocked at her loss and leaves disappointed. Arthur decides that in order to win, all he has to do is cheat, so he pulls out No Guessing! again to find the easy questions. He plants these questions in his sleeves and plants them in the card stack for his friends to ask him, allowing him to win easily.

Arthur starts playing No Guessing! with his friends again, and cheats at every game. At first, no one suspects him in the slightest, but Arthur starts winning everything all the time, and Sue Ellen begins to think he's cheating. Brain can't believe that Arthur would do that. Arthur starts being a "sore winner" and brags about how he wins at everything, and begins cheating in all of their other activities. When his friends play cards, he puts up mirrors so he can see their cards, but says that they only "make the room seem bigger". He also sneezes on purpose during a mini-golf game with Brain, causing him to miss a perfect shot.

Arthur's friends decide Arthur will only go back to normal if he loses again, so they convince Binky to play against him because he has no problem cheating, and thus will win. Binky challenges Arthur and he accepts, with everybody watching him. Arthur gets nervous and finds it harder to cheat. However, Binky is losing because he has no idea how to cheat at No Guessing! Finally, Arthur gets a question wrong, much to the joy of his friends. Fern walks up and tells Arthur that everyone is cheering against him because he's been a jerk to everyone. Arthur then has a daydream where Buster (Who's still away) asks him what's wrong. Arthur says that everyone wants to see him lose, and Buster says it would have been better if he had never cheated at all. He then tells him that since cheating got him into this, he should cheat to lose. Arthur's daydream ends and he finally asks Binky a question, as he was waiting the whole time for Arthur to speak up. Arthur gives Binky all of the easy questions instead, allowing Binky an easy victory. Everyone is ecstatic that Binky won. Unfortunately, when Arthur shakes Binky's hand, the cards fall out of his sleeves, exposing his cheating. Everyone berates Arthur for lying to everyone, and Arthur apologizes for what he did. They all go out to celebrate everything being normal again.

That night, Arthur writes to Buster to thank him for all of "his" advice, apparently forgetting that everything Buster told him was all a dream. The episode ends with Buster reading the letter on his dad's plane, except he has no idea what Arthur is talking about.

Trivia

 * The girl in the no guessing game commercial strongly resembles Muffy Crosswire.

Home Video
DVD:
 * Arthur Makes The Team